After more than a year of constantly changing regulations in all four nations of the UK, we have rewritten this guide and brought it in line with the newest reduced restrictions and guidance, and also the latest thinking on Covid-19 transmission risks and how to mitigate against them.
The main government guidance for which our sector falls under has changed and now comes under general Events and Attractions guidance:
- It is for England, but many of the principles apply for all UK nations.
- It does not specifically mention leisure-time music activity - but is the relevant guidance for venues and groups organising activities in those venues.
- It makes no distinction between professional and non-professional activity.
But if all restrictions are being removed, why would we still need to do a risk assessment and put mitigations in place?
Covid-19 is still with us and new variants are still emerging. All activity is now permitted (soon in all four UK nations), but that does not mean it is permitted without any consideration for the transmission risks which that activity may bring with it.
As the people in charge of a music group, you continue to have a duty of care towards your members and participants when you organise activities and events.
Making Music is here to help. While this document does not write the risk assessment for you, it raises the questions your group should be asking itself and gives you possible mitigation solutions to the risk of Covid-19 being transmitted at a rehearsal of your group.
Government guidance in all nations is increasingly placing the responsibility at organisations’ door to assess Covid transmission risks and to mitigate them appropriately – gone, for the moment at least, are strict rules to adhere to or interpret.
This is good news: every music group is different, has different (kinds of) participants and is based in a different geographical location. A risk assessment means you can reflect the unique nature of your group and put the relevant mitigations in place to reflect that.
But: it means you have to do the thinking and planning – the governments are not doing it for you. We have created this document to help you with that.
Please also note this document is about rehearsals, or other group activity not involving a live audience. For performances with an audience see our separate risk assessment guidance.
- Key questions to address
- Key conversations to have
- Key considerations
- Risk assessment
- Final thoughts and templates
Section one: Key questions to address
- What are you allowed to do?
At the moment we are moving in to a period where most restrictions are being lifted in all four nations, but they may well return and/or continue to differ across the UK, so check our guidance tool once a week for changes – we update this constantly with new information.
- What is the situation in your area?
At the moment all guidance is national with no local restrictions. But keeping an eye on data in your area can help inform what you do. A surge in hospitalisations might make you consider cancelling rehearsal that week. The government coronavirus data summary, updated daily, allows you to drill down into postcodes and local areas.
- What are you trying to achieve with your risk assessment and mitigations?
- That no-one who is knowingly infectious attends your activity
- That if someone (who is unknowingly) infectious attends, no-one else gets infected from that person
- What are the risks now considered to be?
- Aerosols. These pose the biggest risk. They are the smallest particles that we breathe out and carry the virus if we have Covid.
- Being lighter than air, they will float around according to the air flow in that space. Unless you’re a physicist, it will be hard to work out whether the airstream from the violins will end up in the clarinets or the French horns.
- Being so light, they also linger in the air for much longer than larger particles. Think cigarette smoke or perfume, which you can often detect in a room way after the smoker or scented person has left.
- Droplets. These are larger and heavier particles than aerosols and can vary in size.
- Because these are heavier they fall to the ground sooner, but you don’t know quite where or when. There is evidence to show that larger particles do not travel beyond 2 metres from the originating person, hence – until now – the requirement for 2 metres social distancing.
- Surfaces. They could be contaminated if someone had sneezed or coughed on them or touched them.
- hand washing/hand sanitising
- frequent cleaning of surfaces
- Do you want to present a plan to members for their views / input, or do you want to ask them what they want / what would make them feel comfortable before creating your plan?
Asking members their views is vital. But exactly how you do that is worth considering. Asking members first definitely gives them a chance to have their full say, but could leave you with a range of conflicting views that are difficult to balance and accommodate on a practical and financial level.
Presenting a plan and allowing members to comment still gives them a say but might help focus their views. How you present it will be important as members could feel railroaded and not properly consulted. Some who disagree might not feel able to say so once they see a plan and just stay away instead. There could be a ‘third way’ of putting a plan to members with options on details. And, of course, if the overwhelming message is that the plans are not right you still have to listen that.
a) If you are asking members first: what measures will make them feel comfortable coming back?
b) If you are presenting a plan you will need to decide some key things first, including whether you intend to keep some measures that might no longer be required (depending on the nation):
- Social distancing – helps mitigate droplet risk, and there is a case to be made for keeping some distancing (e.g. 1 metre - see Social Distancing)
- Face coverings – helps mitigate aerosol and droplet risk, and there is a case to be made for using them indoors, especially in small, crowded spaces with bad ventilation. (see Face coverings)
- Vaccinations - these are a key reason for the easing of restrictions. As more people are vaccinated, the risks of getting Covid from and spreading Covid to others are reduced. But they do not mean you can remove other mitigations, and you need to be careful about using vaccination levels in your group to inform plans (see Vaccination and testing status).
- Is the venue suitable and as safe as it can be?
This will depend to some extent on the mitigations you want. Key considerations:
- Ventilation – this is crucial and you should not compromise on it (see Ventilation); is it possible to achieve acceptable ventilation; what is the gap between users/hirers and the airing regime; and who is responsible?
- Cleanliness – what happens between users/hirers and who is responsible?
- Size – is it still suitable if you have to / want to maintain some degree of distancing?
- Approach: are they on top of their own risk assessments and procedures?
Read the Making Music resource on finding an venue.
- There may be an ideal plan – but can you afford it in terms of time and money?
If members all want you to keep 2 metres social distancing but that would mean a much larger venue at more cost – is that realistic?
If you need lots more volunteers to run rehearsals safely if everyone comes: do you have these volunteers?
Balance that against your members’ needs in terms of mental and physical well-being
And against the group’s aims of keeping everyone engaged and the group viable into the future
- The musical questions
- Quality of playing/singing. Will that have been impacted? Do you need to rebuild slowly so that people don’t get too frustrated or lose confidence?
- Repertoire. Therefore… is it best to just meet for rehearsals for a term and refresh the music you already know or is it best to programme a concert and have something to aim for, or challenge yourself with a new commission or other music you are unfamiliar with?
- If not everyone is ready to return will you consider hybrid rehearsals? Read the Making Music resource and case study on hybrid rehearsals.
Section two: Key conversations to have
The group of people in charge of your organisation are all responsible, so they need to agree a plan of action together. They will be the ones making the key decisions above and so they should be the first people to meet.
Make sure that is understood and that everyone is contributing and participating in decision-making. If you appoint one ‘Covid-19 guru’, you are still all responsible, so make sure that person or that sub-committee keeps the whole committee informed of what they are doing.
The musical director/conductor/accompanist/other relevant professionals
Their personal situation. They will have to make a choice about whether they want to meet in person or not and what level of mitigations will make them feel comfortable. They might not want to and that is of course fair enough but if members want to and you feel it is safe that shouldn’t stop you – perhaps you need a different (interim?) MD.
Their professional position. It is possible not everyone in the group will return to in-person rehearsals and you may be considering hybrid rehearsals. These will need buy-in from your MD. This is also good to establish in case there is a return of restrictions on in-person activities or indeed to full lock-down.
Why you should ask your members
- Some members might be happy to leave all the decision-making to the committee, others may be desperate to give you their views. Either way, your group is nothing without its members. Keeping them involved and on board (all of them ideally!) is a paramount consideration which informs how you move forward
- Covid-19 is a divisive issue and without asking you won’t know where most of your members sit on the scale of ‘very worried’ to ‘not worried at all’. Finding out as precisely as you can will also help you decide if you need to plan for hybrid rehearsals, or find a new venue, etc.
- Having evidence will help you implement your plans. If 80% of your members say they want to maintain, say, social distancing; then the other 20% will probably accept that, on the grounds that they are in a clear minority.
What to ask members
Essentially you are finding out if your members are ready for in-person activity, and what would make them comfortable enough to attend. You will need to decide whether to do this by giving them a plan to comment / feedback on, or by asking more openly (e.g. giving them options as to length of rehearsals). But the overall aim is to find out what it will take for your group to get its members back into a physical rehearsal space
How to ask members
Make sure everyone gets a say, so if you use our survey but not everyone is responding online, then send out a paper form, get on the phone, or find out members’ views in other ways. The quiet ones aren’t necessarily just happy, they may be intimidated by the more vocal ones, or worry that their view will be unpopular with the rest of the group. Offer anonymity where possible. Make sure they know that the committee wants to please everyone as far as it can, and that even if it doesn’t manage that, it does want to have the full information from everyone in front of it before planning and deciding.
Whether drawn from the membership or not, don’t forget to talk to the volunteers who may be exposing themselves to a greater risk e.g. by setting out the chairs, doing cleaning, checking people into rehearsals etc. Make sure you have protocols for them and provide them with the PPE they would like (e.g. latex gloves).
Your working relationship with the venue you usually rehearse in is very important. Start your conversations early to make sure you have a clear picture of whether they are happy to have you back, what they would expect of you and who is responsible for what.
The venue will want to be sure that you have systems in place which work alongside theirs seamlessly and don’t compromise their own risk assessment. They will not just be thinking about your group, but all the other groups using their venue all through the day and the week, so they will be designing systems and protocols to manage the varied risks associated with a multiple use venue.
But you will also want – and need – to be sure that the venue is fulfilling its duties to keep the public safe, so that your activity can take place in the manner that you consider to be safe. So:
- Ask to see their risk assessment and/or ask them what they are doing with regard to the 6 priority actions (see section below).
- Go and see what they have in place for yourself and in particular to discuss ventilation (see Ventilation below). You may want to do this with a CO2 monitor, to measure air quality.
- Of particular interest to you will also be what is happening in the space before you arrive and whether there is a cleaning and ventilation plan in place between different occupants of the space.
- Be flexible when you can, as they will probably be juggling a lot of different hirers, but if you are unhappy about their risk assessment and don’t consider them a safe venue, take action: either plan for your group to make the space safe (e.g. arriving early to ventilate properly) or consider a different venue – you are responsible for your group and your participants.
- The other aspect to consider (raised by the Events Research Programme) is not just to think about your group once they’re in the space and sitting down, but where in the venue there are pinch points, e.g. entrance/exit, toilets, where the break takes place etc. It is still desirable to avoid bunching people in close proximity; you can manage such pinch points if you are aware of them, so look at your venue with fresh eyes.
Section three: Key considerations
It is worth quoting the entire section from the guidance:
"Encourage customers and visitors to wear face coverings, for example through signage, if your facility or event is likely to include enclosed and crowded spaces.
Face coverings are no longer required by law, but the government expects and recommends that people should continue to wear them in crowded and enclosed settings, to protect themselves and others. Where worn correctly, this can reduce the risk of transmission.
Your workers may choose to wear a face covering in the workplace. You should support them in doing so, and ensure they are aware of guidance on using face coverings safely.
Consider recommending the use of face coverings by workers and customers as a safety measure, in enclosed and crowded spaces where they may come into contact with people they don’t normally meet. When deciding whether you will ask workers or customers to wear face coverings:
- You need to consider the reasonable adjustments needed for workers and customers with disabilities. You also need to carefully consider how this fits with other obligations to workers and customers arising from the law on employment rights, health and safety and equality legislation.
- You should not ask people to wear face coverings while taking part in any strenuous activity or sport.
- Remember that some people are not able to wear face coverings, and the reasons for this may not be visible to others. Please be mindful and respectful of such circumstances. Be aware that face coverings may make it harder to communicate with people who rely on lip reading, facial expressions and clear sound."
So it is clear that there is no legal requirement to wear them (in England), but that you should most certainly consider and debate the use of face coverings if rehearsing indoors, particularly for vocal groups
Chris Whitty said that he himself would continue wearing one in 3 instances:
- Crowded badly ventilated indoor places where he was mixing with people he didn’t normally meet
- If someone in authority who he trusted asked him to
- When it made others uncomfortable if he wasn’t wearing one.
The first and last one of these may be relevant to your group or should certainly be discussed before you take a decision.
There is a recurring theme in all the new guidance about not discriminating against people with protected characteristics, so you should consider this for every measure you consider, including this one.
Get a discount on Sing Safe face coverings.
Because of the increased awareness of the role of aerosols in Covid-19 transmission, the scientists advising government are placing more and more emphasis on ventilation as a crucial tool in avoiding outbreaks.
- Outdoors activity is preferable as transmission risks are a fraction of those in enclosed spaces. Scientific advisors are particularly worried about the autumn/winter when people will increasingly congregate indoors and are more likely to close doors and windows against the cold.
- Indoors in general presents a higher risk, but is worse when it’s crowded. Mitigations that reduce the number of people and time spent indoors can help here. Research also shows that a one off event with a large number of people is less likely to cause an outbreak than frequent events with smaller numbers – so you could even consider fortnightly instead of weekly rehearsals.
- Indoors presents a particularly high risk if badly ventilated. We are already seeing a lot more emphasis on ventilation and this is likely to increase (see Risk assessment: Provide adequate ventilation for information on how to ventilate).
There is some emphasis in new guidance reminding venues and organisations that they must not discriminate against people with protected characteristics. The quote below from the 'Managing your workforce' section of the guidance references workers, but it would be equally applicable to volunteers and participants.
"Consider the impact of your policies on your workers.
- Provide clear, consistent and regular communication to workers of any relevant safety measures or changes to policy/procedure. Engage with workers and worker representatives to explain and agree any changes in working arrangements.
- Consider how this will affect staff with protected characteristics, and any adjustments you should make to take account of your duties under the equalities legislation.
- It is breaking the law to discriminate, directly or indirectly, against anyone because of a protected characteristic such as age, ethnicity, sex or disability. Employers also have particular responsibilities towards disabled workers and those who are new or expectant mothers.
- Discuss with disabled employees what reasonable adjustments can be made to the workplace so they can work safely.
- Assess the health and safety risks for new or expectant mothers.
- Make sure that the steps you take do not have an unjustifiable negative impact on some groups compared to others, for example, those with caring responsibilities or those with religious commitments."
Read the Making Music resource on An inclusive approach to COVID-secure activity.
The vaccination and testing status of an individual does have a bearing on the risk they are exposed to and the risk they present to others. So both can be useful tools for your risk assessment.
- Someone who is double jabbed is less likely to get seriously ill from Covid and is less likely to spread Covid to others.
- Someone who has recently tested negative with a Lateral flow test is less likely to be infectious.
But you have to be careful how you use this information to inform your plan:
- Vaccination and testing are measures to go alongside others, not to replace them. So a room full of vaccinated people should still have mitigations in place, for now.
- Collecting data opens you up to data protection issues.
- Excluding people based on status opens you up to discrimination and reputational risks.
What are the options for finding out people’s status?
- NHS COVID Pass/vaccination certification (differs in the four nations)
The NHS COVID Pass is a way an individual in England can demonstrate that they are fully vaccinated, have had a recent negative test, or have natural immunity. Certification in the other nations is currently not as easy to obtain or comprehensive (e.g. just vaccination status).
Find out more about Covid certification in:
The Event and Attractions guidance (England) says organisations can consider asking individuals to show their NHS COVID Pass. The NHS COVID Pass guidance says:
"Use of the NHS COVID Pass is voluntary for individual organisations. However, we encourage the use of the NHS COVID Pass in facilities or events where people are likely to be in close proximity to a large number of people from other households for a sustained period of time. This is likely to include settings that have the following characteristics:
- crowded indoor settings such as nightclubs and music venues
- large unstructured outdoor events such as business events and festivals
- very large structured events such as business events, music and spectator sport events"
So, you don’t have to use it and a rehearsal would be unlikely to meet the event criteria listed above. But groups do have the option of asking members to show an NHS COVID Pass/vaccine certification. The key things to consider are:
- People don’t have to have the vaccine, or the answer.
- If they have not been vaccinated / won’t answer, what will you do?
- If you exclude on this basis, you would be in danger of discriminating against protected characteristics, e.g. age (not everyone can have the vaccine).
- Exclusion could be a difficult situation to manage that creates division in your group and has a reputational impact. Using vaccination status as a condition might actually create more problems than than it solves.
- Vaccination status is not a replacement for other measures. The measures you should have in place anyway will protect members vaccinated or not.
- There is no issue here with collecting or storing medical data if you are only looking at their pass/status document, not keeping that information.
- Ask members about their vaccination and/or test status (e.g. a survey).
- This has the same issues as above regarding requiring people to do it and excluding people on the basis of their answer or lack of answer
- If you ask for people’s names it creates a data protection issue, as you would be asking for and storing sensitive personal (medical) data
- Ask anonymously
We believe that encouraging members to take up vaccines and do regular lateral flow testing, and finding out (anonymously) whether they have had vaccinations and/or are doing regular lateral flow testing is the best way forward.
- This approach assumes you are not excluding people, so removes the issues and risk associated with exclusion and avoids antagonising your members
- It also removes the issue of storing sensitive data as it would be anonymous
- But it would give you useful data to reflect back to the whole group – e.g. 85% of members are double vaccinated/90% are doing regular tests twice a week - so that should make those who haven’t had the vaccine (for whatever reason) or who are vaccinated but still nervous feel comfortable in attending rehearsals.
- You may wish to repeat the questions (always anonymously) after 3 or 4 months, as the percentage is likely to have changed with continued rollout and/or if lateral flow tests become less easily accessible for people.
Potential future development (England)
It has been announced that double vaccination and/or Covid certification may become compulsory for certain events and settings in England from end of September. DCMS have said that the definition of these events and/or venues has not yet been decided, but essentially they are looking at what they call ‘unstructured events’ – i.e. non-seated (e.g. night clubs); and very large seated events.
This has not been confirmed yet and there are many issues which would need to be resolved, e.g. what about visitors from other UK nations which don’t have the same certification, what about under-18s who will not be offered the vaccines etc.
But if this does go ahead, to avoid having to engage with this issue, you may wish to have seated rehearsal, rather than standing or moving about freely (‘unstructured’).
You, the committee, is responsible for the group activity that happens in a specific place at a specific time. But individuals have to take responsibility also, for:
- making sure they don’t attend if:
- they have Covid symptoms
- they have tested positive
- someone they have close contact with has tested positive
- they have been told to self-isolate
- they have had a recent positive lateral flow test.
- their transport to rehearsals. You can perhaps provide guidance – e.g. car sharing vs public transport vs cycling etc., but ultimately individuals have to take responsibility for that.
- their own health. You can mitigate and minimise risks but you can never eliminate the risk completely that they may be exposed to Covid-19 in the rehearsal room. They need to be aware of that and choose to attend – or not – depending on their own personal circumstances and health.
- their behaviour at the rehearsal or activity you have organised. Provided they receive clear instructions from you as to what they should do and how they should behave (e.g. use hand sanitiser, go outside for the break etc.), then you are fully within your rights to pull them up on their behaviour if they do not conform to those rules. And indeed to make it clear that if there is repeated breach of rules that you may ask them to leave.
It is now no longer a requirement to socially distance in England, but many people are anxious about it and you might decide, or members might request, to keep some level of social distancing. Or you may decide just to ask everyone to give others space and not to assume that suddenly hugging and kisses on the cheek are back on the agenda.
Whatever the decision you should communicate the approach clearly and ask that people are sensitive to others in the group who may feel different about personal interactions to the way they feel themselves.
Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland
All three still have some social distancing measures in place (22 July 2021) see our guidance tool for up to date information. This will obviously impact the number of people that can be accommodated by a venue. Don’t just think about the actual rehearsal space, consider the capacity of all areas (e.g. toilets, break area), how people flow around the venue and measures needed to maintain social distancing throughout.
See Risk assessment: Social distancing for more detail
To help us make the case for the safety of leisure time music should restrictions return, we are asking groups to use the WellRehearsed app. It’s a free and anonymous rehearsal Covid-19 infection reporting app for leisure-time music groups of all kinds, instrumental and vocal, developed by the Association of British Choral Directors (abcd) and Making Music.
It provides statistics on safe group music making during the pandemic, and will help your group, and the sector, in two ways:
- Gathering large amounts of data which can demonstrate the rate and likelihood of Covid infections from making music in a group.
- If anyone does get Covid following an in-person rehearsal, the information it provides will help abcd and Making Music to quickly update our protocols accordingly, giving you the most up-to-date advice on how to protect your group.
Find out more about WellRehearsed.
Section four: Risk assessment
There are 6 priority actions you are asked to take in the guidance to keep attendees safe. These are listed first immediately below.
There are additional points you are asked to consider:
- Each transmission risk (aerosol, droplets, surfaces) and your proposed mitigations (see What are the risks now considered to be, for details)
- A plan in case someone is taken ill at your event
- The impact of your plan on people with protected characteristics
- The specific risks of singing, if your group is a vocal group
- The specific risks identified in relation to events (this would include rehearsals)
- Venue traffic flow and pinch points
- Ancillary activity including refreshments/breaks/transport
Making Music suggests you also consider the risks to your organisation of:
- running or not running in person activity
- the financial and administrative implications of your plans and mitigations
- the impact on your members and participants of your plans and mitigations.
The six priority actions
This will include the following 5 points and others in the guidance, e.g. specific ones for events, and points that we have found need addressing for music groups.
You can use Making Music’s new template and see an example from one of our members below. The Events and Attractions guidance also has a template. It is quite light touch, but useful to see.
"Staff members or customers should self-isolate if they or someone in their household has a new, persistent cough; a high temperature; or loses/has changes to their sense of taste or smell, even if these symptoms are mild. They must also self-isolate if they or someone in their household has had a positive COVID-19 result, or if they have been told to self-isolate by NHS Test and Trace." (from the ‘Priority actions’ section of the Events and Attractions guidance)
Stopping people with Covid coming to your rehearsal is the best way to stop the spread. This largely comes down to personal responsibility on the individuals, but you do have a role to play:
- Remind members about when they shouldn’t come to rehearsal. If:
- they have Covid symptoms
- they have tested positive
- someone they have close contact with has tested positive
- they have been told to self-isolate
- they have had a recent positive lateral flow test.
- Encourage members to consider things like transport routes.
- Encourage members to take regular Lateral Flow Tests twice a week, even if not on the same day as the rehearsal.
"The use of temperature screening products is not recommended by the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency, as there is little scientific evidence to support temperature screening as a reliable method for detection of COVID-19, particularly for asymptomatic cases." (Reducing risk to customers section of the guidance).
There is now an entire section the Events and Attractions guidance on ventilation – we encourage you to read this and act on it, it is really important. "You should make sure there is a supply of fresh air to enclosed spaces where there are people present. This can be natural ventilation through windows, doors and vents, mechanical ventilation using fans and ducts, or a combination of both. You should identify any poorly ventilated spaces in your premises and consider steps you can take to improve fresh air flow in these areas. In some places, a CO2 monitor can help identify if the space is poorly ventilated."
If people with Covid do unwittingly attend your rehearsal, good ventilation is your best defence against spread. Address this as the number one issue for your activity and with your venue.
- Natural ventilation: (i.e. doors and windows) can be very effective. Ideally they would be at opposite ends of a room to create cross flow. High up is good too as the heat of bodies in the room will make aerosols rise and be sucked out via high windows
- Fans: use them in the corners of rooms to prevent build up of stagnant air
- CO2 monitors: these are very helpful in determining the air quality in a room; CO2 presence does not mean there is also Covid in the room, but if there is a lot of CO2 it means the air quality is bad and therefore if there was anyone with Covid in the room, there could be a build-up of virus particles.
- You can use them when you investigate your venue and subsequently before and during rehearsals to see how levels are changing.
- Use them at head height near but not immediately in front of people
- Depending on the size of your space you may need more than one
- Under 800-1000ppm is good air quality
- Anything above 1500ppm requires urgent ventilation/a break and movement of people out of the room
- You can buy CO2 monitors for around £85-100. Avoid the very cheapest as they are not much use.
- See also:
- Air purifiers: You can buy stand-alone HEPA filter machines but note they are quite expensive (£250 approx.) plus for a room of any size you would need several. One will ‘do’ a large classroom, for example, approx.. 140sqm.
- Poor ventilation mitigations: If your venue is not well ventilated or quickly builds up stagnant air as revealed by the CO2 monitor, then consider:
- Changing venue
- Rehearsing outdoors
- Reducing number of attendees
- Shortening length of rehearsals overall
- Shortening rehearsal sections (e.g. 30mins at a time instead of 45mins)
- Lengthening breaks
- Only having rehearsals fortnightly instead of weekly
- Using face coverings
- Don’t cut down on ventilation in the autumn, start instead dressing warm for rehearsals!
- Making Music will roll out more information and events on this topic.
Transmission via surfaces is still a risk, so:
- Continue to provide hand sanitiser and encourage hand washing
- Talk to your venue about pre-clean before your activity, ensure either they or you clean….
- Commonly touched surfaces, e.g. door handles, kettles, taps
- Provide more rubbish ‘stations’ and ensure rubbish emptied regularly
- Ideally still avoid shared equipment (e.g. music stands – if each person brings their own that also helps with continued social distancing)
"You should not introduce measures which involve spraying people with disinfectants (such as in a tunnel, cabinet, or chamber) under any circumstances. You can find more information about these types of measures in the HSE guidance on disinfecting using fog, mist and other systems." (Reducing risk to customers section of the guidance).
This is no longer a legal requirement but is being encouraged, in order to facilitate NHS Test and Trace.
- Whether Test and Trace check-in is available is the venue’s decision. If they do it, make sure you know what they are expecting from you
- Regardless of Test and Trace, it’s a good idea to keep a register of who turns up for which rehearsal so if someone does fall ill, you can let everyone else at that rehearsal know
Communicate your plans and risk assessments to your members, professionals, volunteers, venue
- Separately, let attendees have a simple sheet of instructions which tells them what is expected of them during a rehearsal
- Have poster and visual information reminders of protocols at rehearsals (e.g. signs on hand washing, social distancing if you decide to maintain it, face coverings, traffic ‘controls’ etc.). Use the Making Music Covid poster templates.
- Give members the chance to feedback on the measures, attitudes could change as the Covid situation does.
Additional points to consider and address in your risk assessment
Each of the 3 transmission routes (see What are the risks now considered to be)
|Turn people away*
||Turn people away*
||Turn people away*
||Cleaning more often
||Cleaning more often
*with: symptoms, positive tests, close contact with someone who has Covid, told to self-isolate, need to quarantine after a visit abroad
Social distancing: You might decide or have to (depending on nation) keep some social distancing measures. Some options are
- 2m at all times
- 2m when rehearsing only
- 1m at all times
- 1m when rehearsing only
- No social distancing but ask people to be respectful of each other’s space
- You could limit the number of people allowed in specific areas at any one time (e.g. break room, kitchen, toilets)
- You could have one way and/or queuing systems to control traffic flow at pinch points
Someone becomes ill during a rehearsal: Plan as to what happens if someone is taken ill during a rehearsal or event (unlikely during a short rehearsal, perhaps more so if you’re running a full day event, but worth thinking through)
Discrimination: The impact of your plans on people with protected characteristics and the clinically vulnerable. Check out the government guidance on this. And also read the 7 Inclusive Principles for Arts and Cultural Organisations to help guide you.
Singing: The specific risks of singing, if your group is a vocal group.
The Coronavirus: how to stay safe and help prevent the spread guidance says:
“Some activities can increase the risk of catching or passing on COVID-19. This happens where people are doing activities which generate more particles as they breathe heavily, such as singing, dancing, exercising or raising their voices. You should consider the specific risks of your facility or event, and take additional care to manage situations where there is a higher risk of catching or passing on COVID-19.”
As such we suggest vocal groups address the specific risk of singing in your risk assessment. Some mitigations could include:
- Keep 1m or 2m distance when singing
- Sing side by side (not facing)
- Position singers at the front
- Position singers facing away from or at least 2m from instrumentalists and/or music director/conductor
- Face coverings when singing
- Reduce volume / use microphones
- Only sing in well ventilated spaces
- Take regular breaks
Events: The Events and Attractions guidance has an Additional guidance for event organisers section. Events – i.e. something for a group of people to attend – would include rehearsals here. You have probably addressed these points already by this stage, but it’s worth cross-checking:
- Even outdoors may include indoor spaces (e.g. toilets) where people may gather too close to each other
- Indoors you must address ventilation
- Indoor risks do not necessarily increase with higher numbers of attendees but consider the density of people and adjust number of attendees if venue small
- Risks indoors increase with free movement (e.g. dance floor in night club, so consider seated vs standing choir) because then it’s more likely people come into close contact
- Events with ‘energetic activity’ present a higher risk – this would include vocal groups and singing though you will see they are not specifically referenced here:
- ‘Events involving energetic activity: observations from the Events Research Programme indicate that unstructured and energetic activity with a high crowd density may lead to higher airborne transmission risks. This could include activities such as actively chanting and celebrating while attending sporting events, singing along at gigs and concerts, or dancing/singing at a nightclub.’
Flow and pinch points: Venue traffic flow and pinch points will need to be addressed. Even if you are not using social distancing as one of your mitigations, you still have to ensure that there is no crowding of too many people together in a small space, such as could happen at entrances and exits, in a kitchen, toilet blocks, instrument store room etc.
- Refreshments – none at all? Bring your own? Bring your own cup but you can use the kettle? Is it wise to share cakes or plates of biscuits? What about cleaning before/after – is there someone willing?
- Breaks – where do people take a break and how do they get there? i.e. consider traffic and whether the break area is big enough, how people get there, whether there is enough room to allow people to keep a distance, if they so wish. Ideally have your break outdoors.
Risks to your organisation:
- What are the risks to your group and its objectives if you do run in person events or not?
- will the group fold?
- is it perfectly happy online and thriving?
- Is it able to fulfil its mission with or without in person meetings?
- Can you afford and/or manage the mitigations?
- Additional costs (one-off/ongoing); one-off costs may include CO2 monitors, HEPA filter/air purifier, a pocket amp for your MD so they don’t have to shout; ongoing costs could be disinfectant, hand sanitiser, rubbish bags etc., but most crucially possibly a larger venue
- (Additional) volunteers needed; most groups don’t find it easy to find enough people to help out anyway, so if your risk assessment plans for 4 volunteers at each rehearsal – is that realistic?
- Income from attendees/non-attendees; think carefully about the fees you charge your members – should there be a higher/lower fee for online or in-person rehearsals? What about members who have lost their job over corona – will you have additional concessionary rates? All this will influence your plans: the best-laid plans will be no good if you cannot afford to put them in place
- What are the risks to your members/attendees/participants of meeting in person or not?
- Is their mental health a critical factor here?
- What will be the impact on them if you do or don’t resume activity?
Section five: Final thoughts and templates
"The highest risks of transmission occur when multiple factors are combined. For example, an indoor event with a large number of people mixing in close proximity for a prolonged period of time is likely to present a higher risk than fewer people outside for a shorter period. Transmission can also occur at pre- and post-event activities, such as at restaurants and bars, or on public transport." (from the Phase 1 findings of the Events Research Programme).
This means that the more mitigations you are able to put in place, the more you will reduce the risk of transmission of Covid-19 at an in person rehearsal of your group.
We are all clear that we are not rid of Covid-19; but we are equally increasingly clear that we need to learn to live with it. So understanding about the highest risks for transmission and what measures we can take to reduce those risks will be useful not just for the next few months, but potentially for the next year, or more. It’s worth the effort of engaging with this topic as best you can, therefore!
Risk assessment scoring
Many of you will be aware, perhaps from your ‘day job’, that usually risk assessments score risks before and after proposed mitigations, by multiplying a number (usually between 1 and 5) for the likelihood of something happening with a number (also between 1 and 5) given to the severity if that event should happen.
For instance, without mitigations the likelihood of someone spreading Covid at a rehearsal might be as high as 5 and the severity of the consequence could be that two thirds of the group in the rehearsal catch Covid and several die, another 5. This would give a combined score of 25 – something that definitely is high risk and needs mitigations.
After implementing mitigations, you might consider the likelihood of someone spreading now reduced to perhaps 2 and therefore the severity of the consequence also to 2, as only a fraction of people, if any, would catch it from the infectious person. The new combined score of 4 could then be considered an acceptable remaining risk to the group – or not: these numbers will depend a lot on your group’s situation and also on your committee’s and members’ ‘risk thermostat’ which will determine what is found to be an acceptable level of risk. Remember it can never be zero.
We don’t offer you any scores or numbers in our risk assessment template because each group’s situation will be unique and also because the evidence base for the risks and the best mitigations continues to change.
However, if you would like to use such a scoring system, please find an example submitted by a member group below.
Making Music risk assessment template (example)
Making Music risk assessment template (blank)
Member risk assessment template (with scoring)
Note: all documents are Excel spreadsheets
We hope you find this Making Music resource useful. If you have any comments or suggestions about the guidance please contact us. Whilst every effort is made to ensure that the content of this guidance is accurate and up to date, Making Music do not warrant, nor accept any liability or responsibility for the completeness or accuracy of the content, or for any loss which may arise from reliance on the information contained in it.